About the Course

Founded 1957

Otterkill Golf Course Green Aerial Photo-2

Situated on 136 pristine acres of spectacular vistas, the jewel in the Country Club at Otterkill’s crown is an 18-hole par 72 golf course, designed by William F. Mitchell. The course measures 6860 yards from the Championship tees with a rating of 73.8 and a slope of 139. Otterkill is very playable for all handicappers, as there are four sets of tees from which to play.

Our course has served to host qualifiers for several major local and national events in recent years, including the U.S. Amateur, New York State Open and the MGA Ike Championship.

Course Tour

Hole #1 – Par 5

A 548 Yard par 5, this is a true three shot hole for almost everyone. Beware of the fairway bunker jutting out from the right strategically positioned 80 yards short of the green. Mens HCP 7

Hole #2 – Par 4

A 413 yard par 4 dogleg left where par is a good score. You must hit it far enough to get to the corner of the dogleg and distance control is crucial on your approach. Our tip is to play to the front yardage. Mens HCP 3

Hole #3 – Par 4

A 196 yard par 3 plays a club longer than that due to the change in elevation. Be careful not to short-side yourself as the green runs away from three sides, other than the front. Short is not bad here.Mens HCP 15

Hole #4 – Par 4

A 383 yard par 4 that plays significantly downhill, #4 requires an accurate tee shot placed short of the Otterkill Creek, from which the club gets its name. The green is relatively flat but subtle. Hit the fairway and you might be thinking birdie. Mens HCP 9

Hole #5 – Par 4

A 438 yard par 4, #5 is the number one handicap hole. The fairway turns almost a full ninety degrees to the left, requiring both length and accuracy in the tee shot. The approach is over water to a large green that is both fast and contoured.Mens HCP 1

Hole #6 – Par 4

This 370 yard par 4 has been recently modified with some additional length as well as a new bunker front and left of the severe green. A pond guards the fairway on the left and there are trees on the right, so accuracy is a key. This elevated green may be the fastest on the course.Mens HCP 11

Hole #7 – Par 5

This hole plays every bit of its 561 yards. With out of bounds along the left hand side and thick trees along the right hitting the fairway is essential if you want to have a reasonable length approach.Mens HCP 5

Hole #8 – Par 4

This 380 yard par 4 can be had if you play a good tee shot. An aggressive player will hit driver to give them a shorter approach. The green is guarded by a large tree on the right side. Mens HCP 13

Hole #9 – Par 3

This 190 yard par 3 is the easiest hole on the front side. The hole plays quite a bit downhill but the tee is often sheltered from the wind making club selection difficult. Long and left are out of bounds. Short is not bad here as you will have access to the pin no matter where it is on
this fairly flat green.Mens HCP 17

Hole #10 – Par 4

This 428 yard par 4 plays much longer than its yardage. The fairway runs gently uphill and a large tree protects the green from right side approaches. The green is quite large so choosing the correct club for the hole location is very important. Par is a good score here.Mens HCP 4

Hole #11 – Par 4

This 382 yard par 4 requires an accurate tee shot to a landing area bordered by a pond on the left and a creek that runs across the fairway. The large green slopes significantly from back to front.Mens HCP 10

Hole #12 – Par 5

This 489 yard par 5 is a test of course management. Hit driver and you may have a chance to reach the green in two by hitting over the trees, play it more conventionally and you should be able to hit a short iron approach with your third shot. Mens HCP 18

Hole #13 – Par 3

This beautiful 197 yard par 3 is Otterkill’s signature hole. Large sand traps to the left and right guard the sloped green. Out of bounds lurks to the left of the green so the right-hand trap is very much in play.Mens HCP 16

Hole #14 – Par 5

The 523 yard par 5 dogleg left is a birdie hole. Out of bounds lines the entire left hand side of the hole, and an approach hit long or right may bound down the hill under a tree or out of bounds. Play the hole conservatively and you should make par. Take a risk and eagle is a possibility.Mens HCP 12

Hole #15 – Par 4

The beginning of “Amen Corner”, number 15 is a 437 yard par 4 dogleg right. First you must hit it far enough to get to the corner of the dogleg. With water right and short, sand on both sides, par is an excellent score here.Mens HCP 2

Hole #16 – Par 4

This 324 yard par 4 hole presents water lines the right side of the fairway and fronts the green. The green itself is normally very fast.Mens HCP 8

Hole #17 – Par 3

Par is a good score for this 189 yard, with the right side generally safe.Mens HCP 14

Hole #18 – Par 4

Par is a good score for this 412 yard hole, too, that has a narrow landing area with water left and trees to the right.Mens HCP 6

Recent Facility Upgrades

Under new ownership, Otterkill has been re-investing in amenities for members and events. If you have not see the renovated facilities, come for a visit. We are helping create memories that will last a lifetime

View Photo Gallery

CHALLENGE YOURSELF at

The Country Club at Otterkill

100 Otter Road, Campbell Hall, NY 10916 | Sales@otterkillgolf.com | 845-427-2020